Joe's Provisional Model of God

(Your mileage may vary...)


Joe's Provisional Model of God Version 0.2 — Release Notes

Version numbers describe changes in my understanding of God, not changes in God.


1. The nature of God in this model


God Exists - God is Good - His Reflection is Divine


2. The divine qualities


  • Reflection - The willingness to examine one's own behavior.
  • Consideration - Giving meaningful attention to another person's experience.
  • Humility - Recognizing that one's understanding may be incomplete.
  • Mercy - Allowing room for mistakes, forgiveness, and growth.
  • Honesty - Communicating truthfully and making one's position understandable.
  • Accountability - Accepting responsibility for one's actions and their consequences.
  • Curiosity - Remaining interested in what can be learned from others.
  • Correctability - Being willing to change when new understanding warrants it.


These are provisional qualities, not a complete theological account of God.


3. Reflection and updating as divine processes



God Exists - God is Good - His Reflection is Divine



God

🠇

Original Divine Endowment

🠇

⮫ Experience ⮪

🠇

Reflection

🠇

Consideration of new information

🠇

Revision of understanding

🠇

⮬ Changed behavior ⮭


Continual moral development


Original Divine Endowment: The inherent worth and capacity for experience with which a person enters the world, before language, deliberate reasoning, or the ability to articulate a moral claim.


Goodness isn't limited to never making mistakes.

  • It includes recognizing mistakes, accepting consequences, and becoming more considerate.
  • Regret can be appropriate without requiring permanent self-condemnation.
  • Serious wrongdoing may still require restitution, accountability, protection of others, or reparation.


4. Three places where divine qualities can appear


  1. Relationship - Expression of the ideal, my relationship with myself: Self-respect, reflection, mercy, accountability, and growth
  2. My relationships with others - Reciprocity, acknowledgment, honesty, boundaries, and consideration
  3. My relationships with institutions - Fairness, transparency, accountability, responsiveness, and opportunities for correction.  The institutions include government, courts, businesses, service providers, religious organizations, and other groups.


A good relationship doesn't necessarily mean getting what I want. It means participating in an exchange where the parties' responsibilities and positions can be understood.


5. Civility as a practical expression of goodness


Civility is more than politeness.  It includes:


  •  acknowledging what another person has communicated, considering its substance, responding meaningfully where possible, and remaining open to correction.
  • clarity.  An unfavorable but understandable answer may be more useful than a pleasant answer that leaves the original concern unresolved.


I believe a person doesn't endlessly need justify their discomfort before deciding that a relationship isn't working.


6. What I can and cannot know


I recognize that I cannot completely know another person's

  • motivations
  • every consequence of another person's actions
  • or even every aspect of myself.


I don't claim complete knowledge of God.

  • My moral intuitions and emotional responses can tell me when something deserves attention.
  • Reflection can then help me decide what those feelings mean and how I want to act.


This model is a guide for inquiry and conduct, not a guarantee that every initial interpretation is correct.

This distinction protects curiosity;  which is closely aligned with the divine process of reflection. 


7. Sources of inspiration


My model currently  draws from people whose conduct or ideas I admire.  I haven't researched them extensively yet.  They are human and probably not infallible.


  • Fred Rogers - A possible reference for kindness, listening, dignity, and the value of ordinary human encounters.


  • Sérgio Vieira de Mello - A possible reference for dialogue, humanitarian responsibility, and engagement across differences.


  • James Madison - A source for examining institutional restraint, accountability, and constitutional governance.


  • Thomas Jefferson - A source for examining articulated ideals of liberty and human dignity, alongside the contradictions between those ideals and historical conduct.


  • Joseph Wilbourne Sr. - A model of fairness and responsibility to family.  Always wanting to help.


  • Grady Cundiff – A model of clear communication and trust.  He appeared to approach relationships with an initial assumption of goodwill. The value, limits, and implications of this posture warrant further reflection.


These are proposed connections for further examination, not claims that these individuals endorsed my philosophy.


8. Heaven as an expression of divine qualities


The qualities I associate with heaven may be recognizable in how I live here. 


Mercy, consideration, honesty, reflection, and the opportunity for renewal can be present in imperfect human relationships and institutions.


In that sense, heaven provides an image of what goodness might look like when expressed in everyday life.


9. The model must remain open to revision


If updating my understanding is a divine quality, then my own understanding of God must remain open to updating.  I can learn from religious traditions, philosophers, historical figures, ordinary people, and even institutions whose ideas I initially dislike.  I don't need to adopt their conclusions. I can examine what they have to offer.  And I don't need anyone's permission to develop a personal moral philosophy, although other people remain free to disagree with it.


What remains open


There are substantial questions my model hasn't settled, and that's perfectly appropriate for Version 0.2.

For example:

  • How does God's independent existence relate to my understanding of God as a moral ideal?
  • How should mercy and accountability be balanced when serious harm occurs?
  • what obligations do I have toward people who refuse reciprocity? 
  • how do we distinguish moral intuition from a mistaken interpretation?
  • Can assuming goodwill be an expression of divine consideration while still allowing someone to recognize harmful behavior and establish boundaries?


Life, choice, and autonomy - Some interpretations of divine goodness place the preservation of life above other moral values. Other interpretations assign different priorities to competing values.  In my developing model, choice and autonomy appear fundamental to a good human existence. The inherent value of life must be considered alongside these qualities rather than automatically resolving every moral question. Reflection allows new information and experience to inform our understanding of the choices available to us and the responsibilities associated with them.  I have not established a final hierarchy among these values. Their relationships, limits, and implications require further examination.


Those are ideas and questions I can explore without requiring immediate answers.


A possible statement of my  philosophy


My idea of God is a developing model of the qualities I most value in how I live and how I treat others. I seek to recognize those qualities in myself, in other people, and in the institutions that shape our lives.
Reflection, consideration, mercy, accountability, and the willingness to change are central to that model.
I do not claim complete knowledge of God. I regard my understanding as provisional and open to revision.
I can carry that understanding with me as a guide for living, and I can invite others to examine it without requiring them to share my beliefs.


I've created a model of God in which one of the most important divine qualities is the willingness to revise the model of God.  The Church of Provisional Understanding might have a few theological disagreements at its first meeting.  But at least everybody knows that the bylaws are subject to amendment.

About Version 0.2

Version 0.2 substantially revises and expands my earlier Provisional Model of God. The changes are extensive enough that I have chosen to present the current model in full rather than describe every difference individually.

I apologize to readers who may have expected a conventional incremental update. The earlier version can be understood in the context of a year's worth of reflections on my rapidly changing understanding of who I was in relation to everyone and everything around me. During that time, I was also trying, mostly unsuccessfully, to communicate what I was experiencing to others.


These versions document changes in my understanding of God, not changes in God.